Best Protein Powders at Costco for the Ninja Creami

Levels Vanilla Bean is the ultimate reliable workhorse that I keep coming back to over and over again. It delivers a legitimately craveable experience with a flavor that tastes like real vanilla bean and a dense, silky texture that sets the bar for what a Creami pint should be.

A heavy-hitting contender that defies expectations with its top-tier texture and reliable performance. While the vanilla profile is slightly sweeter than average, its ability to produce an ultra-creamy, top notch, consistency makes it a standout choice for those who value mouthfeel above all else.

Ascent Chocolate is a bit of a tease. It delivers a rock-solid, creamy texture that rivals any premium brand, but the chocolate flavor is just too shy to stand on its own once it’s frozen.

Optimum Nutrition Vanilla Ice Cream is the "safe bet" that doesn't quite hit a home run. While the macros are stellar and the texture is reliably smooth, the flavor loses its punch once frozen. It’s a workhorse protein that gets the job done without any bells or whistles—perfectly fine for a daily habit, but it won't be winning any "Best in Show" awards at The Pint Lab.