The Pint Lab
The Pint LabHigh-Protein Ice Cream Rankings
Menu

Sign in

Log in to leave a review

Community · Mix-in Lab

The Mix-in Lab

Community-ranked mix-ins for your Ninja Creami pints. Sorted by votes, texture integrity, and nutrition. Add crunch without adding 300 calories.

Community RecipesChallenges·
Submit a Mix-in

84

Mix-ins ranked

120

Community votes

38

Under 50 cal

#1
Lily's Dark Chocolate Chips
Lily's Dark Chocolate ChipsLily'sChocolate

1 tbsp (14g)

#2
PB2 Powder (dry)
PB2 Powder (dry)Bell PlantationProtein

2 tbsp (12g)

#3
Oreo Thins
Oreo ThinsNabiscoCrunchy

4 cookies (29g)

#4
Magic Spoon Fruity
Magic Spoon FruityFruityProtein

1/4 cup (9.5g)

#5
Frozen Raspberries
Frozen RaspberriesFruit

1/4 cup (30g)

#6
Frozen Blueberries
Frozen BlueberriesFruit

1/4 cup (30g)

#7
Rice Krispies
Rice KrispiesKellogg'sCrunchy

1/2 cup (15g)

#8
Freeze-Dried Strawberries
Freeze-Dried StrawberriesFruit

1/4 cup (8g)

#9
Mini Chocolate Chips (sugar-free)
Mini Chocolate Chips (sugar-free)Chocolate

1 tbsp (12g)

#10
Cocoa Nibs
Cocoa NibsChocolate

1 tbsp (12g)

#11
Puffed Rice (plain)Crunchy

1/2 cup (12g)

#12
Crushed Graham Crackers
Crushed Graham CrackersCrunchy

2 crackers (14g)

#13
Mini Marshmallows
Mini MarshmallowsOther

1/4 cup (14g)

#14
Wyman's Banana PB Poppers
Wyman's Banana PB PoppersBanana Peanut Butter Chocolate ChipFruit

1 tbsp (13g)

#15
Hormbles Chormbles
Hormbles ChormblesMilk ChocolateProtein

1 bar (32g)

#16
Oreo Cookies
Oreo CookiesNabiscoCrunchy

3 cookies (42g)

#17
Almond Biscotti
Almond BiscottiNonni'sCrunchy

½ piece (14g)

#18
Frozen Strawberries
Frozen StrawberriesFruit

1/2 cup (75g)

#19
Frozen Mango Chunks
Frozen Mango ChunksFruit

1/2 cup (83g)

#20
Frozen Peach Slices
Frozen Peach SlicesFruit

1/2 cup (77g)

#21
Frozen Pineapple
Frozen PineappleFruit

1/2 cup (82g)

#22
Frozen Cherries
Frozen CherriesFruit

1/2 cup (78g)

#23
Banana Slices (Frozen)
Banana Slices (Frozen)Fruit

1/2 medium banana (50g)

#24
Diced Apple
Diced AppleFruit

1/4 cup (40g)

#25
Pomegranate Arils
Pomegranate ArilsFruit

2 tbsp (35g)

#26
Magic Spoon Cocoa
Magic Spoon CocoaCocoaProtein

1/4 cup (9g)

#27
Magic Spoon Frosted
Magic Spoon FrostedFrostedProtein

1/4 cup (9g)

#28
Magic Spoon Peanut Butter
Magic Spoon Peanut ButterPeanut ButterProtein

1/4 cup (9g)

#29
Cadbury Mini Eggs
Cadbury Mini EggsMilk ChocolateChocolate

9 pieces (32g)

#30
Protein Nom Noms
Protein Nom NomsSalted Caramel CrunchProtein

21 pieces (36g)

#31
Hormbles Chormbles
Hormbles ChormblesSalted FudgeProtein

1 bar (32g)

#32
Hormbles Chormbles
Hormbles ChormblesPeanut ButterProtein

1 bar (32g)

#33
Ghost Protein Cereal
Ghost Protein CerealGhostProtein

⅓ cup (13g)

#34
Catalina Crunch
Catalina CrunchChocolate PBProtein

2 tbsp (12g)

#35
Catalina Crunch
Catalina CrunchCinnamon ToastProtein

2 tbsp (12g)

#36
Magic Spoon Cereal
Magic Spoon CerealCocoaProtein

⅓ cup (12g)

#37
Magic Spoon Cereal
Magic Spoon CerealFruityProtein

⅓ cup (13g)

#38
Three Wishes Cereal
Three Wishes CerealCocoaProtein

¼ cup (10g)

#39
Three Wishes Cereal
Three Wishes CerealCinnamonProtein

¼ cup (10g)

#40
Magic Spoon Granola
Magic Spoon GranolaPeanut ButterProtein

1 tbsp (8g)

#41
Magic Spoon Granola
Magic Spoon GranolaMixed BerryProtein

1 tbsp (8g)

#42
Boba Puffs
Boba PuffsTaroProtein

2 tbsp (11g)

#43
Boba Puffs
Boba PuffsMatchaProtein

2 tbsp (11g)

#44
Built Puff Bar
Built Puff BarCookie DoughProtein

¼ bar (11g)

#45
Built Puff Bar
Built Puff BarBrownie BatterProtein

¼ bar (11g)

#46
Lenny & Larry's Complete Cookie
Lenny & Larry's Complete CookieChocolate ChipProtein

⅛ cookie (14g)

#47
Lenny & Larry's Complete Cookie
Lenny & Larry's Complete CookiePeanut ButterProtein

⅛ cookie (14g)

#48
Podium Protein Stroopwafel
Podium Protein StroopwafelPodium WafelProtein

½ wafel (20g)

#49
Premier Protein Cereal
Premier Protein CerealMixed Berry AlmondProtein

¼ cup (10g)

#50
Kashi Go Protein Cereal
Kashi Go Protein CerealKashiProtein

¼ cup (14g)

#51
Reese's Puffs Cereal
Reese's Puffs CerealGeneral MillsCrunchy

¼ cup (10g)

#52
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Cinnamon Toast CrunchGeneral MillsCrunchy

¼ cup (10g)

#53
Ladyfingers
LadyfingersDeLalloCrunchy

2 cookies (17g)

#54
Double Chocolate Biscotti
Double Chocolate BiscottiNonni'sChocolate

½ piece (14g)

#55
Biscoff Cookies
Biscoff CookiesLotusCrunchy

2 cookies (16g)

#56
Pirouette Wafers
Pirouette WafersChocolate HazelnutChocolate

1 wafer (13g)

#57
Pirouette Wafers
Pirouette WafersFrench VanillaCrunchy

1 wafer (13g)

#58
Nilla Wafers
Nilla WafersNabiscoCrunchy

4 wafers (15g)

#59
Graham Crackers
Graham CrackersHoney MaidCrunchy

1 sheet (15g)

#60
Cinnamon Graham Crackers
Cinnamon Graham CrackersHoney MaidCrunchy

1 sheet (15g)

#61
Shortbread Cookies
Shortbread CookiesWalkersCrunchy

1 cookie (14g)

#62
Trefoils Shortbread
Trefoils ShortbreadGirl ScoutsCrunchy

2 cookies (13g)

#63
Milano Cookies
Milano CookiesMilk ChocolateChocolate

1 cookie (11g)

#64
Milano Cookies
Milano CookiesDark ChocolateChocolate

1 cookie (14g)

#65
Chips Ahoy!
Chips Ahoy!OriginalChocolate

1 cookie (11g)

#66
Pocky
PockyChocolateChocolate

7 sticks (12g)

#67
Pocky
PockyStrawberryFruit

7 sticks (12g)

#68
Stroopwafel
StroopwafelDaelmansCrunchy

½ wafel (17g)

#69
Brownie Bites
Brownie BitesToll HouseChocolate

1 bite (14g)

#70
Churro Bites
Churro BitesGenericCrunchy

1 tbsp (9g)

#71
Mochi
MochiVanillaOther

½ piece (22g)

#72
Mochi
MochiStrawberryFruit

½ piece (22g)

#73
Waffle Cone Pieces
Waffle Cone PiecesGenericCrunchy

½ cone (7g)

#74
Sugar Cone Pieces
Sugar Cone PiecesGenericCrunchy

½ cone (6g)

#75
Speculoos Cookie Butter
Speculoos Cookie ButterBiscoffSauce

1½ tsp (8g)

#76
Nutella
NutellaFerreroSauce

1½ tsp (10g)

#77
Caramel Sauce
Caramel SauceSmucker'sSauce

1½ tsp (10g)

#78
Fudge Swirl Sauce
Fudge Swirl SauceSmucker'sSauce

1½ tsp (10g)

#79
Crushed Amaretti Cookies
Crushed Amaretti CookiesGenericCrunchy

2 cookies (13g)

#80
Pizzelle Waffle Cookies
Pizzelle Waffle CookiesGenericCrunchy

1 cookie (11g)

#81
Honey Waffle Crisps
Honey Waffle CrispsLotusCrunchy

1 piece (10g)

#82
Espresso Shot
Espresso ShotOther

1 fl oz (30g)

#83
Toaster Pastry
Toaster PastryBrown Sugar CinnamonProtein

½ pastry (30g)

#84
Protein Donut
Protein DonutVanilla GlazedProtein

1 mini donut (32g)

Know a great mix-in that's missing?

Submit it and let the community vote. The best ones rise to the top.

Submit a Mix-in

Community

See how people use these mix-ins

Browse community recipes to find real pint builds featuring your favourite mix-ins — with macros, photos, and creator notes.

Community Recipes →

Related Guide

Want better texture in your pint?

Mix-ins help, but your base recipe matters more. The Texture Guide covers xanthan gum, thickeners, and the re-spin technique.

Texture Guide →Thickeners →