FlavCity
Salted Caramel
Elite
Score range: 9.0 – 10.0
One of the best protein powders we've tested for Ninja Creami. Exceptional texture, flavor, and macros — this one is hard to beat. Buy this one.
Macros Per Pint
378
Pure Cal
calories
43g
Pure Protein
protein
448
+Oreo Cal
calories w/ Oreos
44g
+Oreo Protein
protein w/ Oreos
Powder sweetener: Stevia Leaf Extract
Contains stevia or inulin. Natural, but can leave a bitter or lingering aftertaste at pint scale — especially stevia, which reads medicinal when frozen.
+ Recipe adds erythritol (from the standard recipe, not this powder). Erythritol is included in all pint nutrition totals below.
Why does sweetener choice matter? →Tested with The Standard Recipe. +Oreo values include 2 Oreo Thins mixed in after spinning.
Full Pint Nutrition Facts
Per Full Pint (pure — no Oreos)
Calculated from the powder's nutrition label + The Standard Recipe baseline (375g Fairlife 2%, 1 tbsp erythritol, 2 tsp non-fat milk powder, 1/8 tsp vanilla extract, 1/8 tsp xanthan gum, 1/2 tsp glycerin).
The Review
Excellent taste and texture. Hard to tell it's not real ice cream. Wanted slightly more caramel syrup texture, but still very good. Would buy again and keep in rotation.
How It's Scored
Flavor Accuracy
Does it taste like what it says on the label? Artificial notes are penalized.
Creami Texture
How smooth and creamy does it spin? Icy or grainy results score lower.
Macro Efficiency
Protein per calorie ratio. High protein, low calories = better score.
Artificial sweeteners (sucralose, acesulfame-K) are noted and generally result in lower flavor scores. Learn more about the methodology →
You Might Also Like
See how it ranks against the rest
Every powder tested with the same recipe, same machine, same honest score.
View All Rankings →This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships have no influence on scores.