Tier Verdict · Solid
A decent option for the Ninja Creami. Works well enough, but there are better choices in the rankings. Decent option if it's on sale.
The Review
Stepping away from the tropical profiles and into the realm of classic summer drinks, running this clear whey through the machine follows a very familiar blueprint. Just like before, treating the mix with a half-teaspoon of citric acid is an absolute requirement to get the flavor profile off the ground and mimic a traditional sherbet base. Texture-wise, it yields exactly what you would expect from the standard Pink Lemonade Lab recipe. There is absolutely no grit, no aggressive foaming, and no icy structural flaws to contend with; it spins up nice, clean, smooth, and clear, behaving beautifully inside the outer bowl on the very first go.
The real differentiator here is how the flavor profile translates to a frozen state. Where a tropical profile naturally lends itself to a beautiful, vibrant sherbet, the pink lemonade flavor feels a bit more muted once spun. It is completely pleasant and leaves a clean, refreshing aftertaste, but it lacks that definitive, mouth-puckering zing you expect when you sit down with a scoop of fruit sherbet. It positions itself more as a gentle, sweet citrus than a bold, tangy standout. It is an incredibly solid, crowd-pleasing spin that would make a great kid-friendly treat, and I certainly wouldn't turn down a pint of it, but it doesn't quite have the flavor density to justify stocking up on a massive supply.
Score Breakdown
Flavor & no off-notes
Creaminess & body
Protein efficiency
Recipe adds erythritol (from recipe, not this powder).
About sweeteners →Macros
Serving size: 1 Scoop (29.6g)
Macros for the protein powder alone, as printed on the label — not including any recipe ingredients.
Per Serving (label)
As printed on the label. Serving size: 1 Scoop (29.6g).
Ingredients
Whey Protein Isolate, Natural Flavors, Malic Acid, Citric Acid, MCT Oil, Acacia Fiber, Coconut Milk, Coconut Oil, Tapioca Maltodextrin, Himalayan Pink Salt, Less Than 0.5%: Sucralose, Vegetable Juice (Color), Reb M (Stevia).
As printed on the label. Always check the current product packaging for the most up-to-date ingredient information.

About This Brand
OATH NUTRITION — #4 Brand · 8.0 avg
OATH NUTRITION is the definitive choice for Ninja Creami users who want to ditch heavy, milky pints for a refreshing, clear protein experience. The Icy Blue Razz is a legitimate standout, delivering a vibrant, tangy sherbet texture with a clean, zesty punch. Island Mango is another incredible sherbet option that avoids the typical protein aftertaste, while the Kiwi Strawberry offers a flawlessly smooth, candy-like treat. If you prioritize light, fruit-forward preparations, this brand is a must-buy for exploring the unique potential of clear protein bases.
Community Reviews
No community reviews yet — be the first to share your experience!
Having texture issues? Icy pints, flat flavor, or grainy texture are almost always fixable.
See the fix guide →This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships have no influence on scores.

