Every Protein Powder Ranked
for the Ninja Creami.

The full master rankings — 83+ protein powders tested in the Ninja Creami using the same recipe, same machine, every time. Scored on flavor, texture, and macros. Includes a full breakdown by flavor profile and protein source.

Top 10 Tier List Browse by Flavor

83 powders tested — updated as new powders are added.

Share:X Facebook Reddit

Get new rankings in your inbox

No spam — just the drop when a new powder gets ranked.

Get new rankings in your inbox

No spam — just the drop when a new powder gets ranked.

The Master Rankings: 500+ Pints, 83 Powders Tested

One base recipe. Zero variables. No more guessing.

This is the most comprehensive database of protein powders specifically tested for the Ninja Creami. Most reviews tell you how a powder tastes in a shaker bottle, but the Creami is a completely different beast. Every entry in this table was tested using my standardized recipe and process to ensure the only thing being judged is the powder itself.

A large collection of protein powder sample packets from over 60 brands tested at The Pint Lab

The sample packet collection. This may take years.

How to use this list

The table below is sorted by my Overall Score, which factors in flavor depth, final texture, and how "craveable" the pint is after a 24-hour freeze.

9.0+ (Elite)

These are the gold standard. They produce a "wow" experience that tastes like real, premium ice cream.

7.5+ (Top Shelf)

Excellent options that I would happily keep in my daily rotation.

6.0+ (Solid)

Good, reliable powders that get the job done but might lack that extra "wow" factor or depth of flavor.

Below 6.0 (Didn't Land)

These just didn't make the cut. Whether the flavor didn't hold up to freezing or the texture felt off, these are the ones I'd suggest skipping to save your money.

Search & Filter: Looking for a specific brand like Ghost or PEScience? Use the search bar to see where they land, or filter by protein source to find the best Whey, Casein, or Vegan options for your goals.

The right powder makes the difference — but so does the recipe. Get the base recipe I use for every single test →