Not yet ranked
We require at least 3 tested flavors before ranking a brand. Orgain currently has 1 tested flavor. Check back once we've tested more flavors.
Flavor Spotlight
Rotates weekly
Vanilla Bean
Despite the massive hype surrounding Orgain’s plant-based formula, it didn’t quite pass the "crave-ability" test at The Pint Lab. While it delivers a recognizable vanilla profile, it’s plagued by those classic, earthy "bean" notes typical of vegan proteins. It’s a perfectly fine option if you’re strictly hitting macros, but don’t expect it to replace your favorite late-night indulgence.
Tested Orgain Powders
1 testedFrequently Asked
Is Orgain good for Ninja Creami?
No commentary yet.
What is the best Orgain flavor for Ninja Creami?
The best Orgain flavor we've tested is Vanilla Bean, scoring 4.3/10. It's our top pick from this brand for protein ice cream. See the full review →
How are Orgain powders tested?
Every powder is tested using the same standardized recipe — Fairlife 2% milk, erythritol, xanthan gum — spun in the Ninja Creami NC301 on Lite Ice Cream mode. Scores reflect flavor quality, texture (smoothness, no graininess), and whether we'd buy a full tub again. See the recipe →
See All Rankings
Compare Orgain against every other brand we've tested — ranked by flavor, texture, and macros.