Rankings
13 protein powders tested
Macros:Per serving, from the label
PowderCalProteinFatCarbsScore
Score:Elite9+Top Shelf7.5–8.9Solid6.0–7.4Didn't Land<6
Menu
The Pint Lab
Protein Powder Rankings
58+ protein powders tested in the Ninja Creami and ranked by score. Sort by macros, filter by flavor or brand, and tap any row for full tasting notes and commentary.
58 powders tested and ranked — updated as new powders are added.
About This List
I've spun 500+ pints testing 0+ protein powders in the same Ninja Creami recipe — same milk, same machine, every time.
Every score is based on taste, texture, and macros. No sponsorships. No affiliate-driven rankings.
Browse by Category
Not sure where to start?
Filter the full database by flavor profile — every category shows only the top-ranked powders, with full scores and commentary.
🍦Vanilla🍫Chocolate☕Coffee🍪Cookies & Cream🥜Peanut Butter🌿Mint Choc🥣Cereal🍓Fruit🧁Dessert✨Unique🏆All Flavors
Each category page includes scores, macros, and full tasting notes.
View All CategoriesFree PDF Guide
New to Ninja Creami? Download the complete beginner's guide.
Base recipe, protein powder selection guide, spin settings, troubleshooting flowchart, and macro math breakdown — all in one printable PDF.